Wednesday, April 28, 2010

American Idol Top 6 Results: Who Got Eliminated?

[Spoilers Ahead]
Bottom 3:
Michael Lynche, Casey James, & Siobhan Magnus

Bottom 2:
Casey James & Siobhan Magnus

Eliminated:
Siobhan Magnus

Everyone did a pretty good job last night so it was clear that tonight was going to be a hard elimination... and anybody in the bottom 3 was going to be a shocker, but I wasn't expecting Siobhan to get eliminated at all. I thought it was time for Michael to go home. THIS is the week where the judge's save would have come in handy, they seriously messed up wasting it on Mike three weeks ago.

10 comments:

Unknown said...

The Judges wouldn't have saved Siobhan... they've been brutal to her for the past 3 weeks, and I think it destroyed her confidence. So sad. I think she should've made Top 3 at least. I disagree that Michael should go home -- I love his voice and his heart. He could win it all. FWIW, I'm voting for Crystal.

Anonymous said...

I am so angry! I can't believe that Siobhan is gone! She was the best left, and this season has had the worst guys ever and they just keep on lasting! It's ridiculous! I'm done. I won't watch anymore. I honestly don't care about any of them left. Crystal's decent, but I preferred Siobhan, Didi, Lacey, Lilly... Worst season EVER!!!!

Anonymous said...

I just can't believe Siobhan got voted off. She's true performer, pushed her self and came out from the comfort zone. Now without Siobhan, the show will be soo boring. I'm so done with this season!

Anonymous said...

wth???
big mike still there...
such a big wasted used the 'save' for the BIG one....look at those face expression..i hate when michael used to show many weirdo face...he's not cute at all..oh please!!!
im from malaysia...and i dont know why american people keeps on put good contestant in axe...
see...alex lambert, lily scot & lacey brown

right now i hope lee and crystal in the final

Anonymous said...

AMERICA YOU F*** DAMN BLIND!
Why'd ya have ta eliminate Siobhan?
She did well this week, it shoulda been Michael!

Anonymous said...

I agree Siobhan shouldnt have left.... but Michael???? Seriously... CASEY shuld've gone!! I don't get why ppl keep saying he's good looking ughhh~ PUKE!!!

Anonymous said...

what a waste of carrie showing up and not performing!

Anonymous said...

Agree with above, why didn't Carrie perform?!?! Sons of Sylvia are NOT good at all.

And agree, Michael should have gone home and should never have been saved.

Casey did a good job this week. Overall, he's been pretty boring but it's clear that Country/Southern Rock is his gig. He could be really good, but could also be a big flop, which admittedly is much more likely.

Anonymous said...

Crystal & Lee are strong contenders.
They should be in the Final 2!

Anonymous said...

Yeah, Crystal and Lee are the ones I always wanted in the finale. I wanted Siobhan to come in 3rd, and I'm sad she won't be around for the last few weeks.