American Idol Top 12: What They Sang

Top 12 Theme:

The Rolling Stones

Michael Lynche

"Miss You"

Didi Benami

"Play With Fire"

Casey James
"It's All Over Now"

Lacey Brown
"Ruby Tuesday"

Andrew Garcia
"Gimme Shelter"

Katie Stevens
"Wild Horses"

Tim Urban
"Under My Thumb"

Siobhan Magnus
"Paint It, Black"

Lee Dewyze
"Beast of Burden"

Paige Miles
"Honky Tonk Women"

Aaron Kelly
"Angie"

Crystal Bowersox
"You Can't Always Get What You Want"

-

Best Overall Feedback from Judges:
Siobhan

Worst Feedback:
Tim